eWhispers
Nov 16, 3:46 PM
FactSet has updated its numbers for the latest earnings season, but its analysis misses a critical point: earnings estimates are not the same as earnings expectations.
https://advantage.factset.com/hubfs/Website/Resources%20Section/Research%20Desk/Earnings%20Insight/EarningsInsight_111326.pdf
And the market's reaction to earnings surprises makes that distinction pretty clear.
132 companies BEAT consensus but MISSED the Earnings Whisper. Their stocks fell an average of 1.5%, with just 43% trading higher.
But here's the more revealing part:
Companies that MISSED consensus but BEAT the Earnings Whisper saw their stocks gain an average of 1.7%, and roughly two-thirds traded higher, despite supposedly missing earnings expectations!
In other words, the market treated many reported earnings beats like misses, while rewarding companies that supposedly missed estimates.
And companies that beat both consensus and the Earnings Whisper gained an average of 2.7% — more than double the 1.1% gain FactSet reports for companies beating consensus estimates.
If consensus estimates are the expectations that matter, why are companies missing those estimates but beating the Earnings Whisper more likely to trade higher than companies doing the opposite?
The market responds to more than earnings per share, but these results suggest the Earnings Whisper is capturing something consensus estimates are missing.
There's a difference between beating the estimate and beating expectations. And the market appears to know it.
So why would you continue relying on consensus estimates to determine whether a company beat or missed earnings expectations?
https://www.earningswhispers.com/investors-sign-up?a=smQ3
$RDDT $HLIO $FTNT $BROS $OPRX
1 replies